Here are the nine players whose performances fell well below expectations at the recently concluded 2026 FIFA World Cup.
Hours after Spain were crowned 2026 FIFA World Cup champions with a hard-fought 1-0 extra-time victory over Argentina at MetLife Stadium, attention has shifted from the celebrations to the players who did not live up to the expectations of fans at the tournament.
While the first-ever 48-team World Cup delivered unforgettable upsets, breakout stars and historic moments, it also exposed some of football’s biggest names. Several world-renowned players arrived in North America carrying the hopes of their nations but failed to produce the performances expected on the sport’s grandest stage.
Here are nine global superstars whose underwhelming displays became defining stories of their countries’ disappointing campaigns.
Lucas Paquetá
Tournament finish: Round of 16 (Lost 2-1 to Norway)
Entrusted with orchestrating Brazil’s attack, Paquetá endured a frustrating tournament. The ex-West Ham midfielder struggled to inject tempo into the Seleção’s midfield, often slowing promising counter-attacks with hesitant decision-making and misplaced passes.
Unable to unlock compact defensive blocks, he was substituted in three of his four starts. His ineffective displays mirrored Brazil’s overall struggles, culminating in a shock Round of 16 defeat to Norway.
Neymar Jr.
Tournament finish: Round of 16 (Lost 2-1 to Norway)
Returning from injury to inspire Brazil, Neymar never looked fully fit throughout the competition. The veteran forward frequently drifted deep in search of possession, unintentionally crowding the midfield and limiting space for Brazil’s attackers.
Despite his experience, the 34-year-old failed to register a single open-play goal contribution, and Norway’s disciplined defence comfortably contained him as Brazil crashed out earlier than expected.
Federico Valverde
Tournament finish: Group Stage
Expected to be Uruguay’s driving force in midfield, Valverde produced one of the quietest tournaments of his international career. The Real Madrid star struggled to impose himself, failing to dictate play or provide the energy and leadership that have become his trademarks.
His subdued performances left Uruguay lacking creativity and control, contributing significantly to their surprise group-stage elimination.
